When I was growing up, I completely trusted my parents. I talked to them about almost everything, and they did everything they could to help me. I didn’t think much about how they knew what to tell me. I just assumed they knew everything that mattered. When I asked a question, they had an answer, and my life is so much better because of them and their guidance.

Now that I am a parent, I realize something that I didn’t know then.

They didn’t always know the right thing. Sometimes they probably had a decent idea what the right thing was, but other times they probably didn’t know what to say at all. What they did know was that they loved me and wanted the best for me. So even when they weren’t right about something or if they just guessed the best they could, the path they were guiding me down was a good one. It was always going to be good for me, and it was.

I have had many moments as a father when I genuinely did not know what to do. I didn’t know how to help, or which way to point, or whether to get involved or to let things play out. In those moments, all I could do was ask others for help, pray, and give the best advice I could, hoping it would turn out right.

What I could be certain of were these things:

  1. I love my kids and want the best for them.
  2. If I were wrong, I would help fix things, and I would learn to do better next time.

As I have thought about the trust I put in my parents, and now the trust my kids put in me, I have asked myself an interesting question. What percent of the time does someone have to be right for us to trust their counsel?

I don’t usually like to admit when I am wrong, but even my rose-colored-glasses assessment puts my accuracy percentage on advice at probably only 70%, and in 25 years my kids and many others may think it was even lower!


What Percentage Is Enough?

I often think about this when I hear people frustrated with their leaders. It might be a church leader, a politician, or a boss. The complaint is usually the same: they got something wrong that had a negative impact, so why should I trust them?

What percentage of the time would a person have to be right to deserve our trust? Eighty percent? Ninety? If a church leader makes ten decisions and gets one wrong, are they still worth following? What about three wrong? What about five wrong?

Digging a little deeper, do we even hold everyone to the same standard?

I don’t believe we do, and researchers have found this to be true as well. In a set of studies at the University of Pennsylvania, people were asked to make forecasts and could choose to rely on a computer model or on human judgment. The computer model was more accurate than the humans. But once people watched the computer make a mistake, they abandoned it far more quickly than they abandoned a human who made the same kind of mistake. The researchers called it “algorithm aversion.” We hold some sources to a standard of perfection that we would never apply to ourselves or even certain others in our life.

This concept is even more interesting when we think about how many people seem to trust the wisdom of the crowd more and more on social media, podcasts, and the internet. BTW, this isn’t just young people; it’s everyone. Most of these influencers or commentators have no stake in our happiness or success, have no verified track record of being right, and we know most of them are far less reliable than people who know and love us. Yet we seem to gravitate more and more toward their counsel than toward that of those who do have a stake in our happiness.

Maybe the gap between expected accuracy and actual accuracy impacts us more? I am not really sure what causes our internal systems to assimilate counsel or reject it fully, but I do feel like bringing decisions around trust into our conscious mind is helpful.

Amelia gave a talk a number of years ago about the Parthenon, and it came to my mind when I was thinking about this idea. So let me tell you a little about it.


The Parthenon

The Parthenon has stood on the Acropolis in Athens for roughly 2,500 years, in one of Europe’s most earthquake-prone regions. Structural engineers have marveled at its complexity and remarkable durability. Its longevity comes from the fact that nothing in its structure is meant to be rigid. There are three key components to its structure:

  1. The foundation blocks of marble rest on bedrock without being secured to it.
  2. Instead of mortar that would have rigidly fixed the marble blocks together, iron clamps and dowels secured them. They were then packed in lead, which helped the iron absorb shocks and protected it from rusting and expanding.
  3. Although its columns look like single shafts of stone, they are in fact stacked drums that can shift slightly against each other.

Archaeologists still debate how much of this was intentional, but either way, the building survived because every part of it could move a little without the whole thing coming apart.

These components and their lasting stability can give us some things to think about regarding trust:

  • The Bedrock of Trust. In my opinion, the first and primary thing that should factor into our trust is whether we are oriented and aligned toward the same ideals and shared outcomes. Fidelity to these ideals and shared outcomes is critical to trust, but just as the marble stones are not rigidly secured to the bedrock, trust does not require those we trust to act, believe, or even think exactly as we do. We just need to know that our shared ideals and outcomes are aligned and real.
  • Shared Experiences Bind Us. We are very imperfect people, and we all make mistakes. Acting perfectly is not what creates trust; rather, it is a willingness to admit our mistakes and seek to reconcile. When we forgive and receive forgiveness, it binds us together because we relate to each other, even if our mistakes are very different. When expectations are perfection, like the computers, any error seems magnified; when expectations are a shared experience, trust doesn’t depend on the absence of error.
  • Trust Only Lasts if Disagreement Can Exist. Like the columns that need to shift in different directions, when we can disagree on things but still feel aligned in our primary purpose, then our trust runs so much deeper, because it is not being measured by accuracy; it is measured by knowing that even when we are shifting in different directions, we can trust they care about what matters most to us.

I think about this stuff all the time, but I want to talk about it here because trust is central to our relationship with church leaders, especially prophets.


The Watchmen on the Tower

In the Old Testament, there are many prophets that I have come to love, but Amos is one of my favorites. At one point, Amos is spreading the word, and a priest at Bethel tells him to go home and stop prophesying. Amos answers the priest, “I was no prophet, neither was I a prophet’s son; but I was an herdman, and a gatherer of sycomore fruit” (Amos 7:14). Amos was not a priest or a theologian; he was not a political leader; he was a farmer, an ordinary man with an extraordinary message given to him from God.

Amos also gives us one of the most quoted verses about prophets: “Surely the Lord God will do nothing, but he revealeth his secret unto his servants the prophets” (Amos 3:7). This is an interesting concept; it makes it seem that God will never do anything without it going to a prophet, but we know that is not true. Every single day, things happen to billions of people that prophets don’t intervene in. It has to mean something else.

I think what Amos means is easier to understand with some context from Ezekiel about prophets. The Lord said to Ezekiel about a prophet’s role, “I have set thee a watchman unto the house of Israel” (Ezekiel 33:7). The watchman’s job is not to know everything happening in the city. His job is to stand on the wall, see what is coming, or the secrets God knows, while it is still far off, and sound the trumpet (Ezekiel 33:1–6).

From the tower, watchmen can see an army miles away that those in the city cannot see, but they cannot see every street in the city, or into our houses. The same distance that lets them see far away is what keeps them from seeing close. Understanding this purpose is critical in engaging with church leaders. They see things that help us from 30,000 feet, but we are the ones living our lives day to day on the ground. Neither view is complete on its own, and knowing their role is to guide us from unforeseen danger is important.


The Mantle

During his life, and for centuries later, Elijah was considered one of the greatest prophets in all of history. When Elijah was taken up into heaven, and his cloak fell to the ground, Elisha “took up also the mantle of Elijah that fell from him” (2 Kings 2:13). Elisha was a farmer, but when he took up “the mantle,” he ended up with a “double portion” of Elijah’s spirit.

I have experienced this concept of the mantle in my life. I served as an elders quorum president three times, twice in Las Vegas and once in Highland. The first call came when I was in my twenties, living in Las Vegas, and not going to church. I didn’t even know the bishop, and it felt like a mistake, but it did change me. I jumped in. I got involved, and I really tried to figure out how to be an elders quorum president. I learned things that made a huge difference, and most importantly it got me to a place where I was ready when I met Amelia, ready to be what she needed me to be.

When I was the elders quorum president in Highland years later, I made a decision about how to run the home teaching program. The usual approach was to give everyone an assignment. I decided instead to give more assignments to the elders who were committed to doing them, and no assignments to those who didn’t want to participate. I felt every family needed someone who would actually show up and love them, and in that moment, that mattered more to me than anything else.

I am sure you can see the irony of my decision. Overall, I think the outcome was really great in that ward, but I am sure there were brothers who became overwhelmed and probably got frustrated with the unfairness of their assignment. I may have also missed opportunities to help someone who, like me years earlier, just needed an assignment to know that God still loved him and wanted his help. Looking back, I still don’t know for sure whether I got it right, but I know that I was trying to do what was best at the time, and I know good things came from the decision, but it probably wasn’t right for each and every person.

Having the mantle isn’t always about doing everything right for everyone. It’s about commitment, a special vision of God’s love, and wanting to help people in the way you know how.


Never Leading Astray

I genuinely believe that prophets and apostles lead our church in a way that God approves. I believe God helps them see things that are very beneficial to our lives. I don’t, however, think they are always right for each person, and that if they say it, I necessarily have to do exactly what they say.

In 1890, President Wilford Woodruff said, “The Lord will never permit me or any other man who stands as President of this Church to lead you astray.” This was spoken at a time when significant changes were happening in the church. This can easily be understood to mean that the President of the Church can never be wrong. This kind of thinking has been very damaging over the years.

It can create too much rigidity in people’s faith, so when a later mistake comes, their faith crumbles with that faulty foundation. Or it can create skepticism in people who assume church leaders expect blind obedience, and they miss out on important guidance for their lives.

“God has not established His Church to make of its members irresponsible automatons, nor to exact from them blind obedience.”
– Elder James E. Talmage

While I am certainly not saying the church is a democracy (when looking around at politics, I don’t know why we would want it to be), it is built on the concept that “all things shall be done by common consent in the church, by much prayer and faith” (D&C 26:2). When we raise our hand to sustain someone, we are not saying we agree with every decision they will ever make. We are simply committing to support them in their efforts.

I believe that President Woodruff was saying something really important. He was saying that God knows the heart of the prophets and apostles; if their hearts are not aligned with God’s to warn us and guide us from the watchtower, then they cannot be the watchmen. This does not mean they will always be right, and like me as an elders quorum president, it does not mean that even if they are right, it will be good for every single situation.

We should listen to the watchmen, think and pray about what they say means for our day-to-day lives, and keep moving forward, trusting they really do care about our happiness and salvation, but also knowing they trust us to make the decisions that are best for us.


Deliberate Damage

Earlier I talked about the Parthenon, and I purposely did not mention that it is no longer a whole building. It survived more than two thousand years of earthquakes, but in 1687, during a war between Venice and the Ottoman Empire, the Ottomans stored gunpowder inside it. A Venetian shell hit the building; the powder exploded, and much of the Parthenon was blown apart in a single moment.

The building was made to handle the ground shaking for centuries. It was not made to handle deliberate damage. This is true for our trust. We should never feel obligated to trust leaders, or anyone who deliberately seeks to deceive, undermine our ideals, or intentionally harm us.


Are We Trustworthy?

As I wrote this post and downloaded conversations I often have with myself, I cannot help but think about what it means to be trustworthy as parents and friends. Are we really thinking about the people we love and what is best for them? Are we aligned with them? Can we tell them hard things in a way that is full of love and compassion? Can we hear hard things from them and love and support them anyway?

I think it is worth doing some inventory of our relationships, whether in business, friendships, or family, and making an effort to build more trust with those we love. In this world of so many voices, having watchmen on the tower, or friends and family nearby, is crucial for all of us.

I am grateful for the people in my life that I trust. I am fortunate to have so many. Friends, family, colleagues, and church leaders. I want their advice, and I am grateful they love me and want what is best for me. I am also grateful for God and the spirit of inspiration and revelation in my life. That inspiration helps me gather all of the guidance I can, and have the confidence to make decisions, knowing that even if they are not always right, I can change and adjust.


ADDITIONAL RESOURCES

Podcasts

  • Faith Matters Podcast: Encouraging faithful inquiry amid complexity.
  • Comeback Podcast: Sharing Stories of those who left the church and came back.
  • Unshaken with Jared Halverson: In-depth historical and doctrinal studies for those wrestling with tough questions.
  • Leading Saints: Insights into modern leadership and discipleship, often addressing nuanced challenges.

Books

  • Saints: The Story of the Church of Jesus Christ in the Latter Days (Vols. 1–2): Thorough Church history, incorporating modern research.
  • Planted by Patrick Q. Mason: A compassionate approach to faith challenges.
  • The Crucible of Doubt by Terryl and Fiona Givens: Thoughtful exploration of faith reconstruction.
  • Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling by Richard Lyman Bushman: A deeply researched biography reflecting Joseph’s certainty and complexity.
  • Making Sense of the Doctrine and Covenants by Steven C. Harper: A summary of the history and context for each section of the Doctrine and Covenants.

Blogs and Articles

  • Gospel Essays: Accessible discussions suited for individual and group study.
  • Faith Matters: Engages contemporary faith topics with candor.